Paper instead of film — when it makes sense
We make both materials, so we have no interest in persuading you to pick one. Below is how they actually differ and when swapping one for the other ends in a complaint.
What slit paper does
When stretched, paper with regular slits forms a honeycomb structure. The air pockets absorb shocks, and the material stretches like stretch film — so it wraps irregular shapes that stiff film cannot cover evenly.
The second difference is storage. Before stretching, paper takes up several times less space than film of similar effectiveness. Where warehouse space is limited, this can matter more than the price of the material itself.
When film wins
Film is a moisture barrier — paper is not and never will be. If a shipment may get wet in transit or the contents are sensitive to moisture, the conversation ends with film.
The second case is electronics. The anti-static version of the film protects against a charge that can damage an integrated circuit without leaving any visible trace. Paper has no such property.
An argument not worth stretching
Paper goes into the same waste stream as the cardboard box, so the recipient does not have to separate it. That is a real advantage and a good argument for a shop that promotes recyclable packaging.
It is not, however, an argument for switching materials where film protects better. Packaging that fails to protect the goods leads to a return and a second shipment — and that is a bigger environmental cost than the difference in material.